| #3 | DePauw | (7,1) | -0.994 | -0.244 |
| #4 | Denison | (5,3) | -0.844 | -0.594 |
| #1 | John Carroll | (7,1) | -0.813 | -0.063 |
| #8 | Kenyon | (1,7) | -0.740 | -1.490 |
| #9 | Oberlin | (0,8) | -0.780 | -1.780 |
| #7 | Ohio Wesleyan | (2,6) | -0.752 | -1.252 |
| #2 | Wabash | (7,1) | -0.911 | -0.161 |
| #6 | Wittenberg | (3,6) | -0.657 | -0.990 |
| #5 | Wooster | (5,4) | -1.013 | -0.902 |